]> Number Fields - Kummer's Lemma

Kummer's Lemma

Lemma: Let ω=e 2 πi/p for some odd prime p. If u[ω] is a unit, then u/u is a power of ω.

[This simple-sounding lemma is more involved than it first appears. At first, I thought it was obvious that any unit is a power of ω, but this is of course obviously false: ω is not a power of ω.]

Proof: Let f[x] be a monic polynomial. Suppose all the roots of f have absolute value 1. Then the sum of the roots taking them r at a time is bounded by ( r n) by the triangle inequality. Thus the coefficient of x r is bounded by this ( r n), hence for any fixed n there are only finitely many algebraic integers α such that all conjugates have absolute value 1 because there are only finitely many polynomials in [x] with given bounded coefficients.

Then consider the powers of α. They are all algebraic integers of degree at most n, and furthermore all their conjugates also have absolute value 1 since the Galois actions map powers of α to powers of its conjugates. Thus the powers of α are restricted to a finite set. This means α is a root of unity.

Now consider the conjugates of u/u, that is u/u for all conjugates u of u. Since complex conjugation is one of the Galois actions they are all algebraic integers with absolute value 1, thus they are roots of unity. Hence u/u=±ω k for some k.

Suppose u/u=ω k. Then u p=u p. But modulo p, we have u p=u p. Thus 2 u p=0 (modp), so p divides u which is a contradiction since u is a unit.